Page 60 - Journal 89-3 Full
P. 60

Data Analysis
                                The recorded interview videos were transcribed first by a computer, then checked
                             and edited by the researcher to verify the accuracy of the transcript. After ensuring
                             the data were correct and complete, the researcher began the analysis process of
                             restorying. In restorying, the researcher creates a framework by “gathering stories,
                             analyzing them for key elements of the story (e.g., time, place, plot, and scene),
                             and  then  rewriting  the  stories  to  place  them  within  a  chronological  sequence”
                             (Ollerenshaw & Creswell, 2002, as cited by Creswell & Poth, 2018, p. 72).


                                                                 Results
                                The pandemic changed how Jennifer and Stephen approached teaching. As the
                             participants navigated through the first 2 years of the pandemic, they experienced a
                             wide range of emotions—from being overwhelmed, to being burned out, to being
                             adaptable. Three major themes emerged from the interviews: human connection,
                             technology,  and  stakeholder  support.  Citations  relative  to  participant  voices
                             throughout the discussion are presented using the format “(Pseudonym, Year, #)”,
                             where the last digit reflects which transcript of the four interview sessions provided
                             the information.

                             Human Connection
                                Both  participants  shared  the  importance  of  human  connection,  not  only  for
                             teaching but for life. Jennifer shared that the lockdown and social distancing caused
                             her  to  miss  seeing  people’s  faces  and  eating  together.  She  commented  that  she
                             felt closer to her grade-level when colleagues could all eat together; she felt she
                             could collaborate informally in the lunchroom. These lunchtime meetings became
                             a  support  system  that  was  sorely  missed  during  the  school  closure.  Part  of  this
                                                              connection resulted from everyone being able to
                                                              see someone’s entire face. Stephen commented
              Both participants shared                        that building relationships is difficult when you

              the importance of human                         cannot see the other person’s entire face.
                                                                  Jennifer and Stephen also shared that face-
        connection, not only for teaching                     to-face instruction can build human connections.
                                                              Both participants attempted to build relationships
                         but for life.                        with  students  irrespective  of  the  in-person,

                                                              distance, or blended modality but found it was
                                                              easier to do so when they were in the same room.
                                                              While teaching in the distance modality, Jennifer
                             shared that it was difficult “to build the relationship with something you can’t even
                             see” (Jennifer, 2021, 2) as many students had their cameras turned off, pointing
                             at the ceiling, or operating in poor lighting. Like Jennifer, Stephen also found it
                             challenging to build relationships with students, despite his best efforts, because the
                             students’ cameras were turned off during instruction.
                                After  struggling  to  build  relationships  remotely,  Jennifer  and  Stephen  were
                             thankful to teach in a blended learning modality from March 2021 through May
                             2021. Jennifer believed her personality came out when the class was together, making
                             class more fun. Stephen felt he could control behaviors better inside the classroom,
                             which helped keep the room cheerful and the students engaged. Furthermore, both
                             participants shared that human connection was easier to build with the smaller class
                             sizes when students were learning from a blended model. The fewer students in the


        58                                           The Delta Kappa Gamma Bulletin: International Journal for Professional Educators
   55   56   57   58   59   60   61   62   63   64   65